A Valentine’s Day Twist: Pairing McCall’s Cheddar with Chocolate
Valentine’s Day doesn’t have to mean crowded restaurants or predictable desserts. This year, celebrate with something a little unexpected: cheddar and chocolate pairings that feel indulgent, cozy, and perfect for sharing. The rich, savory character of McCall’s Cheddar brings balance and depth to sweet chocolates, creating pairings that are comforting, playful, and just right for a night in.
Whether you’re building a simple board for two or looking for a unique after-dinner treat, these pairings offer an easy way to elevate Valentine’s Day with minimal effort.
Caramel-Filled Milk Chocolate + 6-Month Cheddar
Creamy caramel and smooth milk chocolate pair beautifully with McCall’s 6-Month Cheddar. The cheddar’s mild sharpness cuts through the sweetness, while its buttery texture mirrors the caramel’s richness. This pairing is approachable and comforting—ideal for anyone easing into cheese-and-chocolate combinations.
Sea Salt Dark Chocolate + 12-Month Cheddar
Bold, bittersweet dark chocolate sprinkled with sea salt meets its match in McCall’s 12-Month Cheddar. The cheese’s deeper sharpness enhances the cocoa notes, while the salt bridges the savory and sweet. It’s a balanced, grown-up pairing that feels indulgent without being heavy.
Chocolate with Toffee + Porter Cheddar
Toffee-studded chocolate brings crunch, sweetness, and warmth that pairs naturally with McCall’s Porter Cheddar. The subtle malty notes from the porter create a layered flavor experience, making this pairing especially satisfying for Valentine’s Day snacking or dessert boards.
Dark Chocolate Almond + Oak Smoked Cheddar
Nutty dark chocolate and roasted almonds complement the savory, smoky profile of McCall’s Oak Smoked Cheddar. The smoke adds depth, while the almonds echo the cheese’s robust character. This pairing is bold, memorable, and perfect for those who love a more savory-forward finish.
Valentine’s Day is about sharing something special, and these cheddar-and-chocolate pairings prove that simple combinations can still feel thoughtful and indulgent. With McCall’s Cheddar at the center, it’s easy to create a Valentine’s spread that’s cozy, unexpected, and full of flavor—no reservations required.